Jason Austin at an information session at Island View Beach Regional Park. (Tim Collins/file photo)

Island View Beach plan on hold but opposing views persist

  • Jul. 13, 2017 12:30 p.m.

Tim Collins/News staff

The saga of the Island View Beach management plan took an unexpected turn at the Wednesday afternoon meeting of the CRD when board chair, Barb Desjardins, told committee members she had received a letter from the Tsawout First Nation.

The opening paragraph of that correspondence read:

“The Tsawout First Nation does not support the current draft Island View Beach Regional Park Management Plan. (the plan) does not provide a decision -making role for the Tsawout First Nation in the management of our traditional lands that are included within the park”

Gwen Underwood, the Tsawout Lands Manager said that, despite meeting with the CRD for years, their concerns have not been addressed. She went on to say that most of the users of the park are very respectful of the area, but cited dog walking companies who arrive at the beach with up to eight dogs at a time as an example of a practice that needs to be addressed.

“We aren’t just stakeholders in this process. We’ve been here for thousands of years and we need to be treated as a local government,” said Underwood. “It’s why we sent the letter.”

In response to the correspondence, Desjardins called for any decision on the management plan to be delayed until at least August to allow staff to review the issues raised by the Tsawout and respond to the CRD board.

Despite the delayed vote, the Board heard impassioned presentations from ten separate delegations regarding the plan; delegations that highlighted the deep divide that exists between the two sides of the issue.

On one side, the majority of the delegations represented the view of those who, among other issues, want the CRD to live up to it’s responsibility to maintain the berm in the park and keep the drainage ditches cleared to prevent infestations of mosquitoes that plague the area when that maintenance does not take place. That group also generally advocates the human enjoyment of the park, citing the fact that this was agricultural land before being designated as a regional park, not the idyllic natural wetland portrayed by some critics of the active use of the area.

Jason Austin, one of the organizers of the Friends of Island View Beach, presented visual evidence of the failure of the CRD to clear the ditches and said the group would continue to fight to prevent a large area of beachfront on the northern section of the park from being closed to the more than 400,000 annual users of the park.

On the opposing side, three delegations appeared to defend what some have characterized as “the naturalist agenda”.

Ann Nightingale, a Saanichton resident, gave a presentation in which she accused the Friends of Island View Beach as speaking only for their own self-interests. She maintained that she had been made to feel “gullible, simple, foolish, stupid and duped” through her interaction with the organization and went on to criticize the news coverage of the conflict as also being motivated by self interest, although she gave no indication of the nature of the alleged media self-interest.

Several of the delegations also addressed the issue of off-leash dogs in the park with a variety of allegations being levelled by critics of dogs in the park and a series of counter testimonials being offered by long-time park users supportive of the practice who said that dogs posed little or no problem for either the beach or beach users.

The proposed management plan issue will be returning to the CRD in August.

Just Posted

Victoria council narrowly approves transitional housing for former Tally Ho

Neighbours angry about decision to allow temporary three-year permit

Inner Harbour pathway in need of repairs: Harbour Authority

Victoria council approves initial design plans for walkway changes

RCMP open investigation to find missing Sooke macaw

$5,000 reward still being offered for safe return of Rufus

Check out what’s happening in Greater Victoria this weekend

From swimming championships to Oak Bay Light Up, there’s plenty to keep you busy this weekend

VicPD chief rescues lost $10 bill in downtown Victoria

The note was promptly returned to its owner unharmed

Victoria Royals giving a boost to fund inspired by Tragically Hip singer

Downie Wenjack Fund recipient of funds raised starting at tonight’s WHL game vs. Seattle

Nanaimo judge won’t let arsonist have a cigarette lighter

Martin Arthur Taylor previously pleaded guilty to February 2016 arson incident in Nanaimo

BC Ferries vehicle traffic last summer was best ever

CEO says positive results reduce future pressure on fares

Dead rats on doorstep greets Summerland mayor

Two rodents have been delivered to Peter Waterman’s doorstep

False killer whale ‘Chester’ dies at Vancouver Aquarium

He was found stranded near Tofino in July 2014 and only had a 10 per cent chance of making it at the time

Panda picks Argonauts for the win

Giant panda at the Toronto Zoo picks Argos to win Grey Cup on Sunday

Black Friday fervour wanes as some consumers, retailers shun practice

Some businesses are choosing to opt out, while some shoppers are turning to buying online

Stay safe on B.C. roads this holiday season

RCMP warn drivers to plan a safe ride home or suffer the consequences this holiday season

Most Read