Saanich Coun. Nathalie Chambers on a berm in Panama Flats near Baker Street. Chambers says the land is ready to farm, one solution in Saanich’s and the Island’s overall food security problem. (Travis Paterson/News Staff)

Seven years later, Saanich still stalling on Panama Flats

Councillor looks to expedite Saanich’s food security plan

The old swamp known as Panama Flats can grow food, and there’s no reason to wait, according to a Saanich councillor and food security advocate.

First-term Saanich Coun. Nathalie Chambers says there’s nothing holding Saanich back from leasing the fertile land of Panama Flats to farmers during the dry season, even if most of the 26.5-hectare parcel is covered in water during the winter season. It’s an easy solution to start chipping away at the Island’s ongoing food security issue, something she’s been advocating for most of her adult life.

“There are all the indicators of a healthy ecosystem – frogs, all kinds of birds, and bees, you can tell there’s bees here because of the [dense] Himalayan blackberry,” said Chambers, an agricultural advocate who lives and works at Madrona Farm in the Blenkinsop Valley. “When we talk about ‘farming’ I am not talking about conventional methods… I am talking about agro-ecology and the fact farmland benefits many species. And in fact, birds, bees and frogs are signature wildlife indicators of sustainable agriculture.”

Read More: Saanich buys 62-acre Panama Flats for $2.4 million (2011)

Read More: Panama Flats going public to Saanich residents (2013)

The Vantreight farming family owned Panama Flats initially. They leased it to the Galey brothers who farmed it for more than 25 years until last decade. Then Vantreight sold it to a group called Island Berry. By 2010, Island Berry began infilling the flats with dirt, building most of the existing berms that now cross the field and rise above the winter flood. Then Saanich council, led by former mayor Frank Leonard, were limited in what they could do, Leonard recalled.

“Owners complained that the municipality was using private property as a flood plain, which it was,” Leonard recalled.

Add to that the infill and Saanich council was “motivated to have a wetland for storm water storage,” he said, adding, “We lawyered up, it was the only way we could slow them.”

Early in the process of considering a purchase of the land, Saanich staff made a key discovery, that a Saanich sewer pipe runs through the park portion of the northwest corner of the flats.

“Saanich had never acquired a right of way, so that was the tipping point in terms of us deciding to acquire it,” Leonard said. “We didn’t give away the card that we were going to have to pay money one way or another.”

Council approved a deal in February 2011 to give Island Berry $910,000 in cash and an exchange of surplus lands owned by Saanich that amounted to about $2.4 million total. One parcel of land was at Carey and Cherry roads (which was subsequently developed into a nine-lot subdivision with single-family homes in 2013) with another three-lot subdivision at Carey and Roy roads.

The plan was to protect Panama Flats – the West Saanich parcel of land between Carey, Interurban and Roy roads – as a flood plain, a nature refuge and parkland, and also to farm part of it. Originally a swamp drained for agricultural purposes, Panama Flats’s water storage is important for “downstream flood abatement” in the Colquitz River, reads a CRD report.

In 2013 Saanich tried to add a 14.5 ha swath in the middle of Panama Flats to the agricultural reserve (eight of the 26.5 ha property is already in the ALR) however, it ran into barriers with the ALC.

Five years later Saanich’s current agricultural draft plan once again identifies the production of food on Panama Flats as a priority action.

“Ray Galey was the farmer with the pizzazz to farm this place,” Chambers said. “This is how we do sustainable farming. Panama dries up in the summer, it’s called ‘summer starch land,’ where you plant and grow later in the season, July to September. There’s even a massive warehouse here to store equipment and sort food.”

Read More: Former ALC chair Frank Leonard talks pot farms and industrial land

Based on the minimal spring and summer rainfall the South Vancouver Island has received in recent years the growing season could start earlier, she said, adding onions, carrots, potatoes, squash, corn and pumpkins all grow well in that type of land.

However, an up-front investment of infrastructure would have to happen first, starting with the removal of the berms, which are made of fill that Leonard believes may have come from construction sites.

A farmer familiar with site speculated the berms would need to come out and drainage installed, as well as irrigation.

That said, the neighbourhood knows it’s a treasure, “they support this place,” Chambers said.

Chambers also suggested Saanich can consider purchasing similar lands such as the properties of 4140 and 4142 Gillie Rd. part of the Hastings flood plain below Strawberry Vale, which neighbours an active but seasonal farm at Hastings and Granville streets.

(Photos by Travis Paterson/News Staff: Nathalie Chambers opens the barn-style door to the warehouse at Panama Flats. Afternoon skaters take to the frozen fields of Panama Flats in January of 2017. Fertile land sits (at front) unused along Gillie Road next to Hastings Street.)

Unlisted at the moment, Jeff Wonnenberg posted the Gillie Road properties on Craigslist last year, both about 6,800-square-feet, for $100,000 each or $175,000 for the pair. The properties are part of a block grid between Gillie Road and an un-built street, Wallingford Avenue (set out in plans but un-built likely due to flooding), that is zoned single family but are restricted from development as they fall in the flood plain.

“I believe you’re permitted to build a small fruit stand on the property but otherwise you can’t build on it,” said Wonnenberg, a builder who now lives in Sidney. “It’s been in the family for almost 50 years, we’ve been paying taxes but have never able to do anything with it.”

If he can’t sell the land he’s open to fencing it off to lease for an agricultural project, he said, adding he recalls skating over the frozen flooded farm fields along Hastings Street as a child, clipping carrot tops with his blades.

“I’m not a farmer, I’m a builder, but I would love to see this farmed,” Wonnenberg said. “If we sold it, and someone put a house on here, my grandfather [who bought the land] would roll over in his grave.”

reporter@saanichnews.com


Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Man damages Wendy’s in Colwood after getting burger without mustard

Man allegedly ripped off Plexiglas barrier at drive-thru

Cyclists see potential and pitfalls in Sooke infrastructure

Getting from Sooke Road to Galloping Goose Trail a challenge for bike riders

UPDATED: Bear spotted walking on sidewalk near Uptown

Urban sightings prompt warnings from Saanich Police Department

Second bear sighting in a week at View Royal neighbourhood

West Shore RCMP warns residents to not approach black bears

Sidney/North Saanich RCMP look for Lochside Drive robbery suspect

One man arrested with a second man on the run following May 1 robbery

If Trudeau won’t stand up to Trump, how will regular people: Singh

Trudeau did not directly answer a question about Trump’s actions amid protests

Facing changes together: Your community, your journalists

The COVID-19 pandemic has changed the world in ways that would have… Continue reading

Murder charge upgraded in George Floyd case, 3 other cops charged

Floyd’s family and protesters have repeatedly called for criminal charges against all four officers

As two B.C. offices see outbreaks, Dr. Henry warns tests don’t replace other measures

Physical distancing, PPE and sanitizing remain key to reduce COVID-19 spread

Friendly Cove and Kyuquot will remain closed until further notice

Transition of other B.C. communities will be monitored before a decision to ease restrictions

Racist incident shocks Vancouver Island First Nation

Port Alberni RCMP investigating after video shows truck wheeling through Tseshaht territory

Gold River organizes a shop local initiative to creatively boost economy

Local purchases can earn shoppers $200 gift certificates to be spent on businesses within Gold River

Young killer whale untangles itself from trap line off Nanaimo shore

DFO marine mammal rescue unit was en route as whale broke free from prawn trap line

B.C. schools see 30% of expected enrolment as in-class teaching restarts amid pandemic

Education minister noted that in-class instruction remains optional

Most Read